Am I Past My Prime?

Short answer: Maybe.
Better answer: Not in the way you think.

The phrase past your prime hits hard. It carries weight. When someone types that into a search bar—maybe at 11 p.m., maybe after another workout gone wrong or skipped because something more important came up, maybe after looking in the mirror—it’s not just about age.

It’s about identity. It’s about fear. It’s about the loss of something that was not even in your awareness a decade or two ago.

If you’ve asked yourself that question, Am I past my prime?, chances are:

• Your body doesn’t feel like it used to.
• You’re recovering slower.
• You’re carrying more stress, more fatigue, maybe more weight.
• You’re noticing stiffness or pain that won’t go away.
• You’ve tried getting back into shape—but it’s harder than before.
  

And deep down, you’re wondering…

Is this just the new normal?
Is my best behind me?

---

What Does “Am I Past My Prime?” Actually Mean?

Most people think of prime as this mythical sweet spot—somewhere between 18 and 35—where you’re lean, strong, fast, flexible, and energetic. Before responsibilities. Before real injuries. Before sleep deprivation. Before adulting took over.

But that definition is narrow—and honestly, a bit lazy.

Your prime isn’t a number. It’s not a year on the calendar. It’s a phase of performance, and performance isn’t just measured in muscle mass or speed.

Your prime might be when:

• You’re able to train consistently without flare-ups.
• You can chase your kids or grandkids around and not hurt for a week.
• You actually feel good in your body again.
• You’re mentally resilient, physically capable, and emotionally grounded.

For many of the clients I work with, that version of prime comes after 40. Sometimes 50. Sometimes 60.

But only when they stop trying to rewind the clock—and start playing the long game.

---

Why You Feel Past Your Prime (But Might Not Be)

Let’s walk through five reasons why people feel like they’re in decline—and what’s really going on.

1. You Don’t Put Yourself on the Calendar Anymore

Life gets full. Work deadlines. Family commitments. Errands. Appointments. At some point, your name disappears from your own schedule.

Exercise becomes “optional”—until your body reminds you it’s not.

You can’t just fit yourself in when there’s time. If you don’t schedule it, it doesn’t happen. And if it doesn’t happen, everything else suffers: your energy, your focus, your mood, your physical confidence.

Less than 25% of Americans get the basic level of exercise required for health.¹ The scary part is that without burning off that energy through physical activity, your body may redirect it into the immune system, potentially contributing to chronic inflammation and disease processes.²

2. You Accumulate Injuries You Never Fully Rehabbed

You tweak your knee. Your back locks up. Your shoulder aches. So you rest, take a few weeks off, and when it starts to feel better, you go back to whatever you were doing.

It’s fine… until it’s not.

The same injury flares up again, or something else shows up because you’ve been compensating.

Most people never actually finish rehab. This includes those who go to physical therapy and get discharged with all the goals achieved. They stop when the pain goes away—not when the body is ready. The tissue doesn’t get fully restored, and the movement patterns that caused the issue in the first place never get addressed.

Over time, these “old injuries” become the invisible ceiling holding you back.

3. You Remember Your Past Exercise Capacity—Not Your Current Tissue Capacity

This is probably the most common issue I see.

You go back to the gym after months (or years), and your brain still remembers what you used to do:

• The weight you could lift
• The pace you could run
• The number of rounds you could handle
  

So you try to match that—and your body gives you a hard no.

That’s the mismatch between exercise capacity (what you want to do) and tissue capacity (what your body can actually handle right now).

The wider that gap, the more likely you are to get injured, frustrated, or burned out.

It’s not a mindset problem. It’s a load problem.

4. You Prioritize the Short-Term Over the Long-Term

We’ve all done it.

You get motivated—maybe after a bad check-up, a vacation photo, or a birthday that hit harder than expected. So you jump into a challenge, download a new fitness app, or sign up for a race.

For a few weeks, you’re dialed in. You push hard. You cut calories. You train like you’re trying to make up for lost time.

And it works—until it doesn’t.

The problem isn’t that you’re not trying hard enough. It’s that you’re aiming all your effort at short-term wins without a plan to sustain them.

So you burn out. Or get hurt. Or lose momentum the moment life gets busy.

This kind of intensity-first thinking feels productive in the moment, but it’s not a long-term strategy. It’s a cycle—and most people repeat it for years.

If you’re constantly starting over, it’s not a motivation problem.
It’s a planning problem.

5. There Are Too Many Things to Optimize—and It’s Not Clear Where to Start

Once you realize you need a smarter, more sustainable approach, the next trap is information overload.

You start reading articles, following health influencers, listening to podcasts—and before long, your head’s spinning:

• One person tells you to fast 16 hours a day.
• Another says breakfast is essential.
• Someone swears by carnivore, another is juicing, someone else is drinking raw milk and doing cold plunges at 4 a.m.

You’re trying intermittent fasting… then switching to keto… then trying carnivore… now juicing… and somewhere along the way you’re researching whether grounding, red light therapy, or mouth taping will save your hormones.

And they all make it sound like this one thing will finally fix you.

But no one is talking about how to integrate any of it into a real life—especially one with a job, a family, and a body that already feels behind.

What was once just about moving and eating better has turned into a chaotic full-time job of managing gadgets, rules, and contradictions.

The result?

• Decision fatigue.
• Paralysis.
• The constant feeling that you’re doing it wrong.

It’s not your fault. The health and fitness space has become a noisy, fragmented mess. Everyone’s selling a method. No one is teaching a system.

But there is a way through. One that filters out the noise, focuses on what matters, and actually meets you where you are.

Knowledge is potential. Execution is what matters.

---

How to Address the “Am I Past My Prime?” Feeling

Let’s be real—there’s no magic reset button.
But there is a process that works.

The most important mindset shift is to realize you want to move from goals and aspirations to hard skills and systems. Every skill you develop means you need less motivation to perform whatever it is.

Think about riding a bike. If you want to start biking, but have no idea how to actually ride a bike, your motivation has to be sky high and sustained through the hard slog of learning to ride.
Focus on skill development.

And it starts with the most difficult, most important skill:
Put yourself back on your own calendar.

Not as a maybe. Not as a backup plan. As a non-negotiable.

This is the turning point for every client I’ve ever worked with who went from feeling “past their prime” to feeling stronger, clearer, and more capable than ever. It’s the habit that makes every other habit possible.

Being on your calendar means:

• You navigate your own obligations at work and at home
• You learn to say “no” to going out or adding another opportunity
• You must prioritize
• You must anticipate and systematically remove barriers

Once you’re on the calendar, the next step is to start small and stop relying on bursts of motivation.

Motivation will always rise and fall. But ability is something you can build. And when ability grows, confidence grows.

That means:

• Pick one thing.
• Do it well.
• Stick with it until it becomes part of who you are.
• Ignore the fear of missing out on the best thing.

I strongly recommend you start with an exercise habit. 

Not a program. Not a challenge. A habit.

Now—if you have lingering injuries—deal with them properly.
This may need to be addressed before getting your exercise habit.

Don’t try to build strength or endurance on top of dysfunction. Here’s how to approach it:

• Get a real diagnosis – not a vague guess or YouTube theory.
• Learn how to manage it yourself – you need tools, not dependence.
• Rebuild tissue capacity – train your body to handle more.
• Match your exercise capacity to your tissue capacity – this is how you avoid flare-ups and finally get consistent.
• Develop your exercise habit.

Once you’re exercising regularly and your body is holding up, it’s time to move to the next layer: foundational health habits.

Pick one to focus on:

• Water consumption
• Sleep quality
• Basic dietary consistency

Just one. Don’t do a full overhaul. Don’t build a spreadsheet of macros and micronutrients. Start with what you can sustain. 

And please—don’t start with biohacking.

Before you reach for hormone therapy, B12 injections, or the latest recovery gadget, master the basics. Not because those tools are useless, but because they work better when the foundation is solid. You don’t want to add tools that make you feel better but hide a rotting core.

And more importantly:
When your foundation is strong, you often don’t need them at all.

---

🎧 Want to Go Deeper? Start with These Past Your Prime Podcast Episodes:

That’s what Past Your Prime is here for.

Explore the podcasts below or reach out for support and let’s build your system—one skill at a time.

---

1. Episode 6. Getting Back to Exercise: Overcoming Obstacles and Building Habits
A real-world look at how to restart training when life, injury, or exhaustion has knocked you off course—and how to make it stick.

2. Episode 7. How To Start A Workout Routine And Stick With It
A simple but powerful strategy for building sustainable exercise habits, even with work, kids, or low motivation.

3. Episode 3 – When And Why Does Your Diagnosis Matter?
Why having the right diagnosis can make or break your rehab—and how it affects your ability to train and heal long-term.

4. Episode 14 – Understanding Tissues & Pain Mechanisms in Rehab
How to understand what’s really causing your pain—and how to rehab smarter by recognizing the role of different tissue types.

5. Episode 3 – How Do You Stay Active While Managing An Injury
How to keep moving without making your injury worse—plus mindset shifts that help you stay consistent when progress feels slow.

---

Footnotes

1. Elgaddal N, Kramarow EA, Reuben C. Physical Activity Among Adults Aged 18 and Over: United States, 2020. NCHS Data Brief No. 443, August 2022. https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/products/databriefs/db443.htm 
2. Pontzer H, Durazo-Arvizu R, Dugas LR, et al. Constrained Total Energy Expenditure and Metabolic Adaptation to Physical Activity in Adult Humans. Curr Biol. 2016;26(3):410–417. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4803033/

---

Join the Conversation

Have a knee issue or want your case featured in a future Comments Section? Drop a comment on YouTube or ASK A QUESTION.

Follow us on Instagram:
Craig Smith | Alex Keicher